
I Put a Spell on You was created by and stars Johnson. The annual show is a spoof of and tribute to the beloved cult classic movie Hocus Pocus. This year’s COVID-safe digital film is not your average stream: it’s complete with larger-than-life performances and choreography, over-the-top costumes and makeup, unmatched production value and a healthy dose of Broadway magic. This year, the beloved Hocus Pocus-inspired Sanderson Sisters break the internet and recruit some of pop culture’s most iconic villains (think Cruella de Vil, Gaston, The Joker, Maleficent and more) to fulfill their delightfully devious plot. Johnson returns as Winifred Sanderson with Allison Robinson and Amanda Williams Ware as sisters Sarah and Mary.
Cast

Jay Armstrong Johnson
Winifred Sanderson
Allison Robinson
Sarah Sanderson
Amanda Williams Ware
Mary Sanderson
Nick Rashad Burroughs
Unknown

Gavin Creel
Unknown

J. Harrison Ghee
Unknown

Todrick Hall
Unknown
Robyn Hurder
Unknown

Ahmad Simmons
Unknown
Will Swenson
Unknown

Bob the Drag Queen
Unknown
Kizha Carr
Unknown

Marti Gould Cummings
Unknown
Peachez
Unknown

Alexis Michelle
Unknown
Skizzo Arnedillo Arteaga
Unknown
Brittany Bohn
Unknown
Hayden Clifton
Unknown

Tyler Eisenreich
Unknown
Taurean Everett
Unknown
Allison Griffith
Unknown
Gabriel Hyman
Unknown

Karma Jenkins
Unknown
Erin Keith
Unknown
Sarah Kleist
Unknown
Kourtni Lind-Watson
Unknown
Danny Marin
Unknown

Ilda Mason
Unknown
Julia Mattison
Unknown
Jennifer Reed
Unknown

Alanna Saunders
Unknown
Claire Saunders
Unknown
Heath Saunders
Unknown
Cassy Surianello
Unknown
Michael Sylvester
Unknown

Eva Noblezada
Unknown

Drew Gehling
Unknown
Crew
Rick Bieber
Catering Head Chef

Ahmad Simmons
Director, Associate Producer, Choreographer

Jay Armstrong Johnson
Director
Roberto Araújo
Director of Photography
Ling Mai
Director of Photography
Juan Roque
Director of Photography
Jamie Kiliany
Associate Producer
Katie Rosin
Line Producer
Brian Hemesath
Costume Designer
DW
Costume Design
Bobbie Cliffton Zlotnik
Hair Designer, Wig Designer
Kyle Krueger
Makeup Designer
Rocky Noel
Lighting Design
Emily Marshall
Music Director
Will Van Dyke
Music Producer
Alec Addalia
Props
Grady Keefe
Chef
La Palapa
Chef
Melissa Tung
Chef